Sunday, November 23, 2008

A mother's sorrow

I received a call from someone i know requesting to meet in person so as to listen to her grievances. As always, whenever the other party is a woman i made it a point and actually a rule that i shall not entertain her without the presence of another, just to be careful and avoid any untoward incident. That afternoon, my wife was with me when i met her in a Muslim cafe as i felt that we would not be overheard in our conversation for the sake of the woman who told me that it was a family type of problem that she wanted to talk.

We (with my wife) were there first at the cafe before she walked in with a small girl. As they sat down opposite us, i had a better look at both of them. The mother was in her 40s with a sad and heavy physical dispositions obviously from a hard and harsh life. Her hands tell of those who makes a living off the farm or labor-intensive work. The small girl looks the age of 7-8 most with a slim and frail skeleton but innocent-looking big eyes.

I asked them to order a drink just to ease their uneasiness as it must be so when one has to tell of her family problem to an outsider. The woman then thanked us for being there to listen which we politely brushed aside. She told us that the small girl is her youngest daughter and is helping her now because of the school holiday. She is running a mee stalk in one of the coffee shops in town and she doesn't employ anyone as the business is bad and she can't afford an assistant. To make ends meet she also help people to clear land for farming in th elate afternoon.

Then she told us of her real motive to meet, it was to seek the advise as what to do with her second daughter. "What should i do? Send her to the correction center or just treated her as non-existence?"she asked. She was crying then as she told us of the unfortunate family problem with a none committed husband who brought woman back to home and physically abused her and her financial problem in keeping with a daughter in local U and a young 8 years old. But to her sorrow, it was her second daughter who have left her who came back demanding RM65,000 to settle her debt to the loan shark!

"I don't have any money left as i have smashed my youngest daughter piggy bank to pay for my second daughter's debt" she wiped her tears away with her swollen hand as she told us of the heart wrenching story of how she paid some RM1700 plus to settle her daughter's debt. She continued " when i smashed my youngest daughter's piggy bank, i smashed out all the hope left of this family, my own hope and my youngest daughter's as well."
She told us that the 2ND daughter have not come back at all, not even for the Chinese New Year, for the past 3 years although she is in Sibu. The only time when she calls it was always about borrowing money from the mother. One time she called her mother to demand some money for lunch and the mother sent to her all she has left, RM30, and know what she told the mother "Is that all, RM30?" Not knowing to the young girl, her mother told us that on that day, she and her youngest daughter have not eaten themselves as the coffee shop that her stalk opens was closed for almost a week for reason which i didn't even bothered to listen.This time it was a RM65,000 debt that she wanted her mother to pay!

She further told us that because of her family problems lately, her head was so screw-up that on her way back one day, her motorbike was knocked down by a dog and she was hospitalised for a week. She said in her husky voice "what actually hurt was i survive! It would be better if i didn't."

Coming back to the question "what should I do?" I told her that she should just treat her as non-existence and just put her hope on the eldest daughter who should finish her study by next year and raising the youngest one. I told her not to pay a single sen to the loan shark and report to the police if she be harrased by them.

There wasn't any solution when it comes to family's problem. A dishonest husband who abandoned his family with a ungrateful daughter who keep on coming back for money from an uneducated and broke mother and a young 8 years old to raise, what a life that was!

Of course, my wife did offer her our token help which was out of context here to mention. But for us, me and my wife, maybe the encounter offered some sort of reminder that the family value is the key to educate our own children and we did tell our kids about the poor and sorrowful mother and her unfortunate fate.

P/s A mother's sorrow was chosen as the title because that was what hurt the poor woman most as she told us as we walked out of the cafe that she has treated her husband as "dead" already and she just hope that she can bring up her youngest daughter to adulthood before she breathes her last breath.

David Wong
November 2008

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Yes, indeed, this is a sad story. The sadder thing is that there are thousand of similar stories in this society of ours. Like you said, there is no one right answer to stories like this. Even if the woman cuts off her relationship with the 2nd daughter, the question remains whether she and the other daughters would be left in peace by the loan sharks(assuming that the loan sharks story is true and not concocted by the daughter in order to squeeze some money out of her mother).I agree that the best the woman can do in the circumstances is to lodge a police report and leave everything in their hands. Hopefully, ultimately there won't be a heavy price to pay for the daughter's involvement with the loan sharks.

Wong Ho Leng said...

This story is familiar to me, but Hard to advise to treat the 2nd daughter as no more in existence.

I have to listen to the plight of the people virtually everyday. Sometimes I can solve, sometimes there is simply no right answer. As in this case, No, no right answer.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the comment. We all agree that it is hard to decide what to do in this situation as we all have kids.

However, i think when there are only 2 options to choose, we have to come up with the sensible way of dealing taking into consideration of all the parties involved.

In this particular case, the interests of the mother, the girl in question, the two other daughters and one is a minor of less than 10 years old.

If the mother is to be burdened by the debt, then what would happen to the other 2 kids? The eldest one would have to forgo her studies and her hope of fulfilling her own dream as well as to help out the mother. Her youngest daughter might not even have the chance to finish her primary school. The mother might collapse and end up either in the mental institution or involve in another accident because of the load in her mind.

I am not a heartless person but my sympathy has to be with the innocent ones and the weight in this case is against the ungrateful daughter.

Of course, there are many such incidents and we have seen many families broken up because of one (1) member in the families. We are not God and we can't solve all these problems.

Like Ho Leng said, there isn't any right answer. My advise is based on the circumstances and taking into consideration of the interests of all the parties.

P/S I have spoken to the girl in question and found that she is simply in a state of denial. She has no respect for her family and asked me why did i get involve at all.

Wong Ho Leng said...

A lot of wrong people are in a state of denial. This much is expected. It is human nature. I once had to advise a man who had a relationship with another woman. In front of the sobbing wife, he asked me, "Are you advising me as a lawyer or as a YB?"

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

this really is a sad story.. but if i m the 2nd daughter i'll ask my mum to move out from that house.. All the ppl in this world will done sth wrong, n i blif that if they willing to giv the 2nd daughter a chance, i think she'll change but of cause it need a lot of time. we should pray for them although we dono who are them..

David Wong's blog said...

It is not easy to moderate comment, on one hand we always think we should comments as they are but on th eother hand we need also to protect individuals whose good name mignt be smeared by certain interested parties.

But i am sure if we look at the comments, we also know certain are quite doubtful and untruthful and many surfers would prefer these allegations to be delected.

One thing is for sure, we will try to be as open as possible as some would attack us as "too defensive".

DAVID WONG'S BLOG

MOUTH PIECE 4 SARAWAKIAN

Blog Archive

Labels